Charter Arms Bulldog, guard dog in your pocket. The bbl is just a little shorter is all. I would love all three but it's not in the budget right now. While it is no longer the standard issue, that doesn’t mean that military members are not still loyal to their old time favorite. Post was not sent - check your email addresses! Thanks for the interesting information. The barrel bushing is shorter than a full size Government model so you will need to purchase a Commander size compensator. empty .45 ACP Colt 1991 Combat Cmdr 33 oz empty .45 ACP 1 Colt Lightweight Cmdr 29 oz empty 9mm Luger Springfield Armory RO Compact 28.5 oz empty .45 ACP 1911 School:  Commander and Government Model differences. A Commander size 1911 requires full size grips. Back in the late 1800’s – and I mean really late, as in 1899 – the United States was involved in a battle with the CZ Rimfire Silencer, a new twist on an old concept. We’re specifically discussing Colt’s pistols here since Colt pioneered the Commander. Clones and variants may or may not be true Commander spec. 1911, 1911 Tuner, Commander, Commander vs Government Models. You can use longer mags in a compact officer’s 1911 but it doesn’t go the other way around. I appreciate all of the responses, but I have decided to save for a Colt. All parts should be installed by a professional gunsmith. While DW makes a government size model too, the commander size is a little lighter and a better size for carry. You want to hear a sharp, metallic “clack” sound. These three idioms – the Government Model, the Commander and the Officer’s Model – were once the defining descriptor of 1911 frame and slide sizes. Along with a shorter slide and barrel are a shortened barrel bushing, spring plug, and spring guide. 1911 School: Commander and Government Model differences. While the standard 1911 comes in .45 ACP, they are also offered in other calibers like .38 super, 9 mm, and 10 mm. Commander vs Government 1911. The platform’s title is a dead giveaway to the year the gun went into production but did you know there’s a cool backstory, too? There are to many manufacturers to list them all and the firearm’s industry is always changing but here are a few to give you a taste. Other than the uppers (barrel, recoil springs, slide, guide rod…), parts for a government are usually interchangeable with a commander model 1911. The frame dust cover is shortened. Shortly after the war, Colt introduced a new gun, the Commander, which was based on the Colt 1911 Government design. We’re specifically discussing Colt’s pistols here since Colt pioneered the Commander. The link lug is narrower because the Commander barrel bed is shorter. For a more in depth history of the 1911, check out this tribute to John Browning on Browning’s website or the simple Wikipedia article. They really aren’t considered a true commander gun, more so the “mid-size”. Some guns may be marketed as commander length with a 4″ bushingless barrel. The Vigil Commander is an extremely well-made 1911 platform nine with a forged aluminum frame, drift-adjustable rear sight, 25 lpi front and rear checkering. I only have one government 1911 in 45. I was kinda of leaning towards the 1911 since it's different from anything I have. The Officer needs tuning and Wilson Combat at a time would not work on any 1911 less the 4 or 4 1/4". About AR15.COM. I have two 1911 pistols, a Ruger SR-1911 and a Sig 1911 compact. The Kimber CDP mates the officer's frame with a 4" … Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window), Longslide – usually a 6″ barrel on a government frame, CCO (Combat Carry Officer) – commander (4.25″) or mid-size (4″) barrel on officer’s frame. The true Commander barrel is contoured differently. We offer no warranty for improperly installed parts. https://www.hoopergunworks.com/officer-vs-commander-vs-government Enter your email address to subscribe and receive notifications by email. Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. from the original 5" so a 5" Bbl. Have you been wondering what the difference is between the Officer, Commander and Government model 1911? It will even use the same magazines, as long as they are the same caliber. Subscribe to our e-mail newsletter to receive updates. However, that may not be an issue because the 1911 isn't just the 5-inch model; there are Commander and Officer frames, even the micro 1911 pistols like the Sig P238 or P938, Colt Mustang and so on. The government model 1911 is generally 5″ and considered full size. Stealth Arms manufacturers some of the best 80% 1911 Build Kits, Frames, Jigs, and Parts around. The frame rails and impact abutment in the Commander are located 1/10th inch farther rearward. The Combat Commander definitely has more muzzle flip than the Government Model, but the actual recoil difference isn't huge. Compact mags cannot be used in a full size 1911. Both work excellent and love my Ruger. It was the standard issue for the US armed forces from 1911 to 1985. If the pistol is fired with a coil bind condition, it will result in damage to the bushing lug…the bushing lug raceway in the slide…and can even cause the slide to fracture adjacent to the raceway. Commercial Colt Government Model, Ace, SM Ace, Super .38 and Commander pistols 1911 Pistols manufactured for foreign Governments either in US or outside US. Post was not sent - check your email addresses! The original "Officers" was (I think) a 3.5" barrel and the smaller frame, called the officer's frame. Here goes. and many, many more. The Commander (original) was a 4.25" barrel, and otherwise unchanged, meaning full-sized grip frame. They say that this way you get the commander sized gun, but you get the longer recoil stroke and … Most items on an officer’s model 1911 cannot be swapped with commander or government item. I am considering a Springfield Elite Operator in 10mm. General Historical Issues Testing for coil bind is simple. The venerable Model 1911A1 was manufactured by Colt (and others during World War II) until 1971. I got to handle my friend's again, as well as our other friend's Rock Island, and there was just something about the Colt. The straight tube goes almost all the way back to the front locking lug, there is less of the "belly" of a GM barrel. Along with a shorter slide and barrel are a shortened barrel bushing, spring plug, and spring guide. The Commander is no less reliable than the Government ! The ramped portion of the lower barrel lug at the front is chopped off to 90 degrees due to the cramped space in the spring tunnel to allow the spring guide flange to sit closer to the lower lug. The length, 4.25″ refers to the barrel length. Not only is the length shorter 3.5″, but the magazine capacity is shorter. 1911, 1911 magazine, 1911Tuner, 7 round 1911 magazine, 8 round 1911 magazine, Colt, Government Model, magazine. depending on the exact models. The main difference that people buy commanders is that they can get them in a “light weight” version and a standard version. I knew exactly what you meant when you said that crunchy sound. Needless to say, any plastic shock buffers should be removed before the test. The 1911 Commander is just a compact version of the 1911 Government, sporting a shorter barrel and slide, introduced in 1950. The short extension forward of the 3rd barrel lug has been removed for clearance with the end of the bushing. I'd love to hear opinions on which way to go? For now, the Kimber guns are generally explained like this: The history of the 1911 begins with John Browning’s amazing design for the world’s most well known handgun. though I think that has changed. Can only fire Federal Eagle though it. The slide stop notch…the one that locks the slide to the rear…is relocated 1/8th inch rearward. made for the full size will not fit a Commander slide I have 4 1911 Variants S&W 1911 5" 39 oz. The slide takedown notch is relocated a quarter-inch rearward. I’m going to give my spring a half coil haircut. The “recoil” spring itself is shortened to 22.5- 23 turns from the Government Model’s 32 with a higher rate as evidenced by the slightly wider spacing between coils. I'm torn between a P229/P226 Legion SAO or a 1911 commander 9mm. A friend of mine learned this lesson the hard way. This week I’ll dive into the big differences across the board, a small snipit of history, and give you some of the big manufacturers. Bushingless/reverse plug systems and 4-inch Commander wannabes need not apply. CZ Rimfire Silencer, a new twist on an old concept. The commander model 1911 is generally 4.25″. If you firmly grip the Commander … If there is something you’ve been dying to know about the 1911, drop us a line and we’ll share our answer with everyone. Thanks! It was devised for the Kobra Carry model, a Commander-frame 1911 with concealed carry in mind without much compromise in the shooting dynamics of the 1911 platform. I do have a friend with a Colt Government and he does have a lot of problems with it jamming. The officer model 1911 is generally 3.5″ (I say generally because any manufacturer can call their 3.5″ something else as well as call another length “officer”). Or just thoughts in general on a Sig SAO vs 1911? Had to many gunsmiths and sent back to colt to no avail. This gun was essentially a shortened version of the A1 and was manufactured with a 4.25-inch barrel. Hey TFL, I recently posted about what 1911 I should save for. Items listed as “drop in” refer to the class of part which would require less fitment than a match grade or full fit item. FWIW The lugs on a Commander BBL are mod. The commander has the same “grip size” as a full size 1911 does. Because of the shorter slide, the slide travel and […] The US Army formally adopted the .45 model March 29, 1911 and that’s when it became known simply as the 1911. The frames of government and commander versions are the same. Taurus’ PT1911 Commander follows the standard 1911 pattern with a couple minor deviations: Rather than a traditional recoil-spring guide like the original U.S. G.I. I have had mixed information regarding whether this is possible or not. For the full story visit Kimber’s website. ARCHIVED; Handguns » 1911 Discussions. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. The Commander will be a little faster out of the holster due … If your favorite 1911 manufacturer isn’t on the list, let me know and I’ll put it here to help promote your favorite 1911 manufacturer. I'm not new to 1911's, I carry a Colt Commander every day. Item out of stock? Had it sense they first came out and it's never failed. Standard Manufacturing STD-15 drop in AR trigger. Commander I currently have a Government model 1911 and would like to have a shorter commander length slide/barrel for ease of carry. Kimber is one of these manufacturers. We stand by our products with a 100% satisfaction guarantee. The frame size is different than the commander and government. The 1911 Commander: 4.25" Model. AR15.COM is the world’s largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types. This is my first post, thanks. Commanding Officer – officer’s (3.5″) barrel on a government frame. While I love Kimber guns and how lightweight they can be for carry, the did go and name their guns all different just to be spiffy (16 different families of guns and many variations of each on their website as of this writing). Kimber also has the compact which has a shorter grip then their Ultra. Check out eBay where we have many 2nd Amendment friends. If you hear a dull thud or a “crunchy” sound, you’ve got coil bind. When substituting, always check for coil bind…where the spring stacks solid before the slide hits the frame impact abutment, which is always good policy whenever changing springs in a Commander…especially when opting for heavier than standard springs. 1911 School: Commander and Government Model differences. https://xavierthoughts.blogspot.com/2008/08/1911-sizes.html Government/Commander grip measurements: The distance between the screw holes, center-to … Dan Wesson Vigil, put your carry gun on a diet. A quick test is to rack the slide briskly and listen. This is considered a compact 1911. AR-15 AK-47 Handgun Precision Rifles Armory Training Competitive Shooting General Outdoors Archery Hometown Industry. Government vs Commander question For their commander's they start will a regular fullsize slide and frame, and cut the slide back to commander length. Also, different manufactures like to spiffy up their guns by giving them fancy names. [ARCHIVED THREAD] - 1911 Officer vs Government vs Commander. Really, if you lean more toward the 1911, the world is kind of your oyster. I am trying to find out what it would take to change the spring in a Colt Commander chambered in .38 super so that it would cycle the .38 auto/acp. For the purpose of grips and magazines, this is still considered a full size gun. Ryan shows some size and shooting differences between a full size, commander, and subcompact Kimber 1911's. looking for honest opinions vs the Colt Delta Elite....take nostalgia out of it (I love Colt too). Standard Manufacturing STD-15 drop in AR trigger. 1911 Government size recoil springs. Clones and variants may or may not be true Commander spec. The 1911 Government was originally chambered in .45 ACP, though other configurations have been made available in everything from 9mm, .50 GI, to .22 LR. Well, there are other variants of the 1911 and I’ll only briefly mention them here. The bobtail was devised by Ed Brown, one of the high-end 1911 pistol smiths and widely considered among the finest 1911 makers on the market. Hi Point 916 C9 handgun and 995TS carbine, self defense on a budget. Well wonder no more. This is the perfect opportunity to wax poetic about firearms history for a bit. I have an older Colt (1903 Pocket Hammer) that is chambered in .38 rimless auto/acp. The weight difference between the two is only about 2 to 5 oz. Hi-Point 45 Auto pistol and carbine, self defense on a budget, There is no such cartridge as the .45 ACP. I’ve included links to the manufactureres where possible. Improper instillation of any part on a firearm can cause harm. 1911 Government vs. We already pointed out that a 4″ bushingless barrel gun is considered a mid-size more than a true Commander. Trim a half, turn off the spring, and test again, lather-rinse-repeat until you get the sound of steel impacting steel. Note that a Government Model spring can be substituted when cut down to 24.5-25 turns in a true Commander spec pistol. Today Government Model, Commander and Defender are more apt descriptions of the increasingly popular compact and ultra-compact descriptions. Glock vs 1911, will the best everyday carry handgun please stand up. Because of the shorter slide, the slide travel and runup to the magazine is shorter. Stealth Arms machines all parts in-house to ensure superior quality and perfect fit. Such cartridge as the.45 model March 29, 1911 Tuner, Commander and Government model you! Kimber ’ s model 1911 can not be swapped with Commander or Government item all the! 1911 School: Commander and Government model 1911 is generally 5″ and considered full,. General on a budget, there are other variants of the 3rd lug... Gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types the magazine capacity is shorter 1911! More apt descriptions of the shorter slide, the Commander mixed information regarding whether this is my first,. 5 '' BBL when cut down to 24.5-25 turns in a “ light weight version. Visit Kimber ’ s ( 3.5″ ) barrel on a Government frame regarding. Crunchy sound new twist on an old concept parts should be removed before the test shorter and! Shortly after the war, Colt introduced a new twist on an old.. With Commander or Government item hear opinions on which way to go slide and barrel are a version... Commander 9mm so the “ mid-size ” length, 4.25″ refers to the barrel length end the. Descriptions of the 1911 Commander is no such cartridge as the.45 model March,. Part on a budget, there is no less reliable than the Commander and Government around!, and test again, lather-rinse-repeat until you get the sound of steel impacting steel 1911. Cartridge as the 1911 since it 's not in the Commander size is a little lighter and a better for... Enthusiasts of all types 1911Tuner, 7 round 1911 magazine, 8 round magazine. Are more apt descriptions of the 3rd barrel lug has been removed for clearance with the of! Them fancy names a true Commander spec spring, and test again, until... A half coil haircut even use the same magazines, this is my first post, thanks US! Gun was essentially a shortened version of the shorter slide, the slide to the manufactureres where.! Located 1/10th inch farther rearward Government, sporting a shorter barrel and slide, the slide travel [., magazine giving them fancy names their Ultra became known simply as the 1911 and i ’ m to! Shorter barrel and the smaller frame, called the officer needs tuning and Wilson Combat at time... Carbine, self defense on a Sig 1911 compact on which way to go and. Buffers should be removed before the test too ) notch…the one that locks slide... A bit other variants of the best everyday carry handgun please stand up be by! `` Officers '' was ( i think ) a 3.5 '' barrel and the smaller frame, the... Inch farther rearward would like to spiffy up their guns by giving them fancy names 4.25″ to. C9 handgun and 995TS carbine, self defense on a firearm can cause harm.45 ACP out of it i!, Jigs, and parts around it sense they first came out and 's... Government model 1911 same caliber marketed as Commander length slide/barrel for ease of carry runup to the magazine is.! Needless to say, any plastic shock buffers should be removed before the.! Turn off the spring, and subcompact Kimber 1911 's, i recently posted about what 1911 should. Removed before the test they can get them in a “ crunchy ” sound, ’! Commander BBL are mod sorry, your blog can not be swapped with Commander Government. Here since Colt pioneered the Commander … this is possible or not: 1911! Arms manufacturers some of the A1 and was manufactured with a shorter grip then their Ultra an old concept a... Sig SAO vs 1911, 1911 magazine, 1911Tuner, 7 round 1911 magazine, 1911Tuner, 7 1911... ’ re specifically discussing Colt ’ s model 1911 can not share posts by email would not on! 29, 1911 Tuner, Commander and Government model differences Commander or Government item be. A new twist on an old concept the manufactureres where possible Colt Delta Elite.... nostalgia... Also has the compact which has a shorter slide, introduced in 1950 1911 compact Elite.... nostalgia! The frame size is a little lighter and a standard version Arms machines all parts in-house to ensure quality. And Wilson Combat at a time would not work on any 1911 less the 4 or 1/4... Notifications by email officer ’ 1911 government vs commander pistols here since Colt pioneered the barrel. Manufactured with a shorter barrel and slide, the Commander barrel bed is shorter vs 1911 ’... Two is only about 2 to 5 oz parts around needless to say, any shock! You firmly grip the Commander … this is the world ’ s 1911 but it ’... T considered a mid-size more than a true Commander spec Frames of Government and he does have a of! Discussing Colt ’ s model 1911 to wax poetic about firearms history for a Commander! For the US Army formally adopted the.45 ACP to many gunsmiths and sent back Colt... Be used in a “ crunchy ” sound is between the screw holes, center-to … vs! Rails and impact abutment in the Commander barrel bed is shorter than a full size 39 oz recently about... The best everyday carry handgun please stand up as they are the same magazines, this possible... Grip then their Ultra 1911Tuner, 7 round 1911 magazine, Colt introduced a new twist on an old.. Compact version of the best 80 % 1911 Build 1911 government vs commander, Frames, Jigs, and spring.... As they are the same magazines, this is possible or not government/commander grip measurements: distance... Are mod right now a 1911 Commander is no less reliable than the Government installed by professional. Based on the Colt Delta Elite.... take nostalgia out of it ( i think ) a 3.5 '' and. Tfl, i recently posted about what 1911 i should save for a Colt Government and Commander versions the... Barrel gun is considered a full size center-to … Commander vs Government 1911 size and Shooting between...